Being in a car accident is stressful enough, but the decisions that follow can be just as overwhelming, especially when it comes to replacing your vehicle. Should you invest in a brand-new car with all the latest safety features, or opt for a reliable used vehicle that won’t break the bank? Each option comes with its own set of pros and cons, from cost considerations to long-term value and peace of mind.
In this post, we’ll break down the key factors to consider when choosing between a new or used car after an accident. Whether you’re looking for affordability, reliability, or the best bang for your buck, we’ll help you weigh your options and make the right decision for your situation.
Evaluating Car Replacement Options
Making the right choice between new and used vehicles after an accident requires careful analysis of damage severity, financial implications, and insurance factors.
Assessing the Extent of Accident Damage
Before deciding whether a new car is necessary, it’s a good idea to get a professional opinion on whether the car involved in the accident can be repaired. Not all cars can be repaired to a road-safe level but in some cases, the cost of repairs can be more affordable than purchasing a new or used car.
A reputable mechanic will be able to give you a fair evaluation of the costs required to fix any damage to a car to determine if going ahead with repairs makes economic sense. Though exterior damage is usually apparent after an accident, internal damage is less obvious and a thorough inspection will help to reveal any hidden problems that might affect long-term reliability.
When repair costs exceed 70% of the car’s pre-accident value, most experts recommend going ahead and purchasing a replacement vehicle rather than paying for repairs. This threshold helps prevent investing in repairs that won’t restore the vehicle to safe, reliable condition.
Understanding Depreciation and Value
Cars are one of the fastest depreciating purchases meaning that they lose a significant chunk of their value from the point that they are purchased. In fact, new cars typically lose 20-30% of their value in the first year and about 60% over five years. Used vehicles experience a more gradual depreciation curve, which for many people makes them financially attractive options.
Pre-owned vehicles with documented maintenance histories and clean accident records often provide the best value for the majority of people. Used cars that are between 2 and 5 years old balance modern features with reduced depreciation impact.
The resale value of cars is impacted by several factors including:
-
- Make and model reputation – Cars from a reputable brand are likely to depreciate in value less as they are in higher demand.
- Mileage – The more miles a car has done, the more ‘worn’ it is and therefore the lower its value.
- Maintenance history – Cars that have had repairs in the past due to an accident may be worth less, though good upkeep and regular servicing can be beneficial.
- Local market demand – As with all products, car prices fluctuate depending on availability and demand.
Insurance Considerations
Insurance payouts significantly influence replacement options. Most policies offer actual cash value (ACV) for vehicles that have been totalled, meaning that they are beyond repair and must be scrapped. The amount that is paid out reflects the pre-accident market value minus depreciation.
Gap insurance covers the difference between ACV and loan balance which protects drivers against negative equity. This coverage can be especially valuable for new car purchases that require minimal down payments.
Some insurers may even offer new car replacement coverage for vehicles that are under 2 years old. This benefit ensures that drivers receive equivalent new models rather than depreciated values.
Comparison of New and Used Cars
Making the choice between a new or used car involves evaluating purchase costs, safety features, and maintenance plans. Each option presents distinct benefits for post-accident vehicle replacement.
Cost Analysis
The average cost of a new car in 2025 is around $45,000 – $50,000. In comparison, the average cost of a used car is around 30-40% less than this. In both cases, finance options are usually available which allows drivers to make monthly payments towards the cost of the car rather than paying for it entirely up front.
Insurance rates typically run higher for new vehicles because they cost more to replace if an accident occurs. Naturally, this means that used cars often cost less to insure, with average premiums 15-20% lower than new vehicles.
Financing terms typically favor new cars, with interest rates averaging 1-2% lower than used car loans. Manufacturers are interested in getting their new cars into the market and onto our roads, hence it’s common for them to offer special financing deals and cash incentives on new models.
Safety and Technology Features
Newer cars are likely to have better and more modern technologies that come as standard compared to used cars. This includes better safety innovations, such as advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) and improved crash protection structures.
Nowadays, it’s common to see car models include safety features including:
- Automatic emergency braking
- Lane departure warning
- Blind-spot monitoring
- 360-degree cameras
- Enhanced airbag systems
These technologies are relatively new which means that the majority of used cars are unlikely to include them.
Warranty and Maintenance
New cars include comprehensive factory warranties, typically covering:
- 3 years/36,000 miles bumper-to-bumper
- 5 years/60,000 miles powertrain
- Complimentary maintenance for 2-3 years
Used cars may retain some factory warranty coverage depending on age and mileage. Extended warranties can provide additional protection but increase overall costs.
Maintenance costs generally rise with vehicle age. New cars require minimal maintenance in their first years, while used vehicles may need more frequent repairs and parts replacement.
